Section 4 Side, stern doors and other shell openings
Clasification Society 2024 - Version 9.40
Clasifications Register Rules and Regulations - Rules and Regulations for the Classification of Naval Ships, January 2023 - Volume 1 Ship Structures - Part 4 Military Design and Special Features - Chapter 3 Special Features - Section 4 Side, stern doors and other shell openings

Section 4 Side, stern doors and other shell openings

4.1 Symbols

4.1.1 The symbols used in this Section are defined as follows:

d = distance between closing devices, in metres
k s = material factor, see Vol 1, Pt 6, Ch 5, 3.1 Design criteria 3.1.1 but is not to be taken less than 0,72 unless demonstrated otherwise by a direct strength analysis with regard to relevant modes of failure
= moment of inertia, in cm4, of the stiffener or girder, in association with an effective width of attached plating determined in accordance with Vol 1, Pt 6, Ch 2, 5 Dynamic loading
σ = bending stress, in N/mm2
σe = equivalent stress, in N/mm2
=
σo = minimum yield stress of the bearing material, in N/mm2
τ = shear stress, in N/mm2

4.2 General

4.2.1 These requirements cover service doors in the ship side (abaft the collision bulkhead) and stern area, below the weather deck and in enclosed superstructures.

4.2.2 For the requirements of bow doors, see Vol 1, Pt 4, Ch 3, 3 Bow doors.

4.2.3 Side and stern doors are to be so fitted as to ensure tightness and structural integrity commensurate with their location and the surrounding structure, see also Vol 1, Pt 3, Ch 1, 5 Definitions

4.2.4 In general, the lower edge of door openings is not to be below a line drawn parallel to the design draught.

4.2.5 When the lower edge is below the design draught or doors below the vertical limit of watertight integrity are to be opened at sea, the arrangements will be specially considered. In general, the enclosed spaces protected by the door are to be considered open as well as closed in damage stability or flooding conditions.

4.2.6 Doors are generally to be arranged to open outwards, however inward opening doors will be considered provided strongbacks are fitted when the doors are situated in the first two lower decks above the waterline.

4.2.7 For ships complying with the requirements of this Section, the securing, supporting and locking devices are defined in Vol 1, Pt 4, Ch 3, 3.3 Symbols and definitions.

4.3 Construction and testing

4.3.1 Plans are to be of sufficient detail for plan approval purposes. Plans showing the proposed scantlings and arrangements of any side and stern doors or other shell openings are to be submitted. Side and stern doors or other shell openings are to be constructed under survey.

4.3.2 Side and stern doors fitted below the limit of watertight integrity are to be subject to a pressure test of a prototype to confirm the design pressure head.

4.3.3 As an alternative to prototype testing, the integrity of the door may be demonstrated by calculation and representative testing in accordance with MSC/Circular.1176 – Unified Interpretations to SOLAS Chapters II-1 and XII and to the Technical Provisions for Means of Access for Inspections – (25 May 2005) . For doors fitted above the vertical limit of watertight integrity, the doors only require testing following installation, in accordance with Table 6.7.1 Testing requirements in Vol 1, Pt 6 Hull Construction in Steel.

4.4 Scantlings

4.4.1 In general the strength of side and stern doors is to be equivalent to the strength of the surrounding structure.

4.4.2 Door openings in the side shell are to have well rounded corners and adequate compensation is to be arranged with web frames at sides and stringers or equivalent above and below, see Vol 1, Pt 3, Ch 1, 5 Definitions.

4.4.3 Doors are to be adequately stiffened, and means are to be provided to prevent movement of the doors when closed. Adequate strength is to be provided in the connections of the lifting/manoeuvring arms and hinges to the door structure and to the ship structure.

4.4.4 The thickness of the door plating is to be not less than the shell plating calculated with the door stiffener spacing, and in no case to be less than the minimum adjacent shell thickness.

4.4.5 Where stern doors are protected against direct wave impact by a permanent external ramp, the thickness of the stern door plating may be reduced by 20 per cent relative to the requirements of Vol 1, Pt 4, Ch 3, 4.4 Scantlings 4.4.4. Those parts of the stern door which are not protected by the ramp are to have the thickness of plating in full compliance with Vol 1, Pt 4, Ch 3, 4.4 Scantlings 4.4.4.

4.4.6 Where higher tensile steel is proposed, the plating thickness required in Vol 1, Pt 4, Ch 3, 4.4 Scantlings 4.4.4 and Vol 1, Pt 4, Ch 3, 4.4 Scantlings 4.4.5 may be reduced by .

4.4.7 The section modulus of horizontal or vertical stiffeners is to be not less than required for the adjacent shell framing using the actual stiffener spacing. Consideration is to be given, where necessary, to differences in fixity between ship’s frames and door stiffeners.

4.4.8 Where necessary, door secondary stiffeners are to be supported by primary members constituting the main stiffening elements of the door.

4.4.9 The scantlings of such primary members are to be based on direct strength calculations. Normally, formulae for simple beam theory may be applied to determine the bending stress. Members are to be considered to have simply supported end connections. The design load is the uniformly distributed external sea pressure, p e, as defined in Vol 1, Pt 4, Ch 3, 4.9 Design loads 4.9.1. For minimum scantlings, p e is to be taken as 25 kN/m2 and the permissible stresses are as follows:

4.4.10 The webs of primary members are to be adequately stiffened, preferably in a direction perpendicular to the shell plating.

4.4.11 The stiffness of the edges of the doors and the hull structure in way are to be sufficient to ensure weathertight integrity. Edge stiffeners/girders are to be adequately stiffened against rotation and are to have a moment of inertia not less than:

= 0,8 P L d 4 cm4

where

P L = packing line pressure along edges, not to be taken less than 50 N/cm.

For edge girders supporting main door girders between securing devices, the moment of inertia is to be increased in relation to the additional force.

4.4.12 The buckling strength of primary members is to be specially considered.

4.4.13 All load transmitting elements in the design load path from door through securing and supporting devices into the ship structure, including welded connections, are to be to the same strength standard as required for the securing and supporting devices. These elements include pins, supporting brackets and back-up brackets. Where cut-outs are made in the supporting structure, the strength and stiffness will be specially considered.

4.5 Doors serving as ramps

4.5.1 Where doors also serve as vehicle ramps, the plating and stiffeners are to be not less than required for vehicle decks, see Vol 1, Pt 4, Ch 3, 2 Vehicle decks and fixed ramps

4.5.2 The design of the hinges for these doors should take into account the ship angle of trim or heel which may result in uneven loading of the hinges.

4.6 Closing, securing and supporting of doors

4.6.1 Doors are to be fitted with adequate means of closing, securing and support so as to be commensurate with the strength and stiffness of the surrounding structure. The hull supporting structure in way of the doors is to be suitable for the same design loads and design stresses as the securing and supporting devices. Where packing is required, the packing material is to be of comparatively soft type, and the supporting forces are to be carried by the steel structure only. Other types of packing may be considered. Maximum design clearance between securing and supporting devices is generally not to exceed 3 mm.

4.6.2  Devices are to be simple to operate and easily accessible. They are to be of an approved type.

4.6.3 Securing devices are to be equipped with mechanical locking arrangements (self locking or separate arrangements), or are to be of gravity type. The opening and closing systems as well as securing and locking devices are to be interlocked in such a way that they can only operate in a proper sequence.

4.6.4 Means are to be provided to enable the doors to be mechanically fixed in the open position taking into account the self weight of the door and a minimum wind pressure of 1,5 kN/m2 acting on the maximum projected area in the open position.

4.6.5 The spacing for cleats or closing devices should not exceed 2,5 m and there should be cleats or closing devices positioned as close to the corners as practicable. Alternative arrangements for ensuring weathertight sealing will be specially considered.

4.7 Systems for operation

4.7.1 Doors with a clear opening area of 12 m2 or greater are to be provided with closing devices operable from a remote control position. Doors which are located partly or totally below the vertical limit of watertight integrity with a clear opening area greater than 6 m2 are to be provided with an arrangement for remote control from a position above the vertical limit of watertight integrity. This remote control is provided for the:

  1. Closing and opening of the doors.

  2. Associated securing and locking devices.

4.7.2 The location of the remote control panel is to be such that the opening/closing operation can be easily observed by the operator or by other suitable means such as closed circuit television.

4.7.3 A notice is to be displayed at the operating panel stating that the door is to be fully closed and secured preferably before, or immediately the ship leaves the berth and that this operation is to be entered in the ship’s log.

4.7.4 Means are to be provided to prevent unauthorised operation of the doors.

4.7.5 Where hydraulic securing devices are applied, the system is to be mechanically lockable in the closed position so that in the event of hydraulic system failure, the securing devices will remain locked. The hydraulic system for securing and locking devices is to be isolated from other hydraulic circuits when in the closed position.

4.8 Systems for indication and monitoring

4.8.1 The following requirements apply to doors in the boundaries of special category spaces or vehicle spaces, through which such spaces may be flooded. For ships, where no part of the door is below the design waterline, doors that are to be opened at sea are above the vertical limit of watertight integrity, and the area of the door opening is not greater than 6 m2, then the requirements of this Section need not be applied.

4.8.2 Separate indicator lights and audible alarms are to be provided on the navigation bridge and on each operating panel to indicate that the doors are closed and that their securing and locking devices are properly positioned. The indication panel is to be provided with a lamp test function. It is not to be possible to turn off the indicator light.

4.8.3 The indicator system is to be designed on the fail safe principle and is to indicate by visual alarms if the door is not fully closed and not fully locked, and by audible alarms if securing devices become open or locking devices become unsecured. The power supply for the indicator system is to be independent of the power supply for operating and closing the doors and is to be provided with a back-up power supply. The sensors of the indicator system are to be protected from water, ice formation and mechanical damages.

4.8.4 The indication panel on the navigation bridge is to be equipped with a mode selection function ‘harbour/sea voyage’, so arranged that audible alarm is given if the vessel leaves harbour with side shell or stern doors not closed or with any of the securing devices not in the correct position.

4.8.5 Where not already installed, a Closed circuit television surveillance and a water leakage detection system, of approved type and suitable for the intended location, shall be arranged to provide both a visible and an audible indication to the navigation bridge and to the main machinery control station of any leakage through the side or stern doors, or any other shell openings which could lead to major flooding.

4.9 Design loads

4.9.1 The design force considered for the scantlings of primary members, securing and supporting devices of side shell doors and stern doors are to be taken not less than:

  1. Design forces for securing or supporting devices of doors opening inwards:

      External force:
      F e = Ap e + F p kN
      Internal force:
      F i = F o + 10W kN
  2. Design forces for securing or supporting devices of doors opening outwards:

      External force:
      F e = Ap e kN
      Internal force:
      P i = P o + 10W + F p kN
  3. Design forces for primary members:

      External force:
      F e = Ap e kN
      Internal force:
      F i = P o + 10W kN
      whichever is the greater.

The symbols used are defined as follows:

p e = external sea pressure, in kN/m2, determined at the centre of gravity of the door opening and is not to be taken less than:
  • for ZG < T 10 (T – ZG ) + 25 kN/m2
  • for Z GT 25 kN/m2
  • For stern doors, p e is not to be taken less than:
p emin =
T = design draught, in metres
Z G = height of the centre of area of the door, in metres, above the baseline
L R = length of ship, but need not be taken greater than 200 m
λ = coefficient depending on the area where the ship is intended to be operated:
= 1 for sea-going ships with service area notation SA1, SA2 and SA3
= 0,5 for ships operated in sheltered waters with service area notation SA4
C H = 0,0125L R for L R < 80 m
= 1 for L R ≥ 80 m
A = area, in m2, of the door opening
W = weight of the door, in tonnes
F p = total packing force, kN. When packing is fitted, the packing line pressure is to be specified, normally not to be taken less than 5 kN/m2
F o = the greater of F c and 5,0A kN
F c = accidental force, in kN, due to loose cargo, etc. to be uniformly distributed over the area A and not to be taken less than 300 kN. For small doors such as bunker doors and pilot doors, the value of P c may be taken as zero, provided an additional structure such as an inner ramp is fitted, which is capable of protecting the door from accidental force due to loose items.

4.10 Design of securing and supporting devices

4.10.1 Securing devices and supporting devices are to be designed to withstand the forces given above using the following permissible stresses:

The terms ‘securing device’ and ‘supporting device’ are defined in Vol 1, Pt 4, Ch 3, 3 Bow doors

4.10.2 The arrangement of securing and supporting devices is to be such that threaded bolts are not to carry support forces. The maximum tensile stress in way of threads of bolts, not carrying support forces, is not to exceed:

4.10.3 For steel to steel bearings in securing and supporting devices, the normal bearing pressure is not to exceed 0,8σo, see Vol 1, Pt 4, Ch 3, 4.1 Symbols 4.1.1 For other bearing materials, the permissible bearing pressure is to be determined according to the manufacturer’s specification. The normal bearing pressure is to be calculated by dividing the design force by the projected bearing area.

4.10.4 The distribution of the reaction forces acting on the securing and supporting devices may require to be supported by direct calculations taking into account the flexibility of the hull structure and the actual position and stiffness of the supports. Small and/or flexible devices, such as cleats, intended to provide load compression of the packing material are not generally to be included in these calculations.

4.10.5 Only the active supporting and securing devices having an effective stiffness in the relevant direction are to be considered in the calculation of the reaction forces acting on the devices.

4.10.6 The number of securing and supporting devices is generally to be the minimum practicable whilst complying with Vol 1, Pt 4, Ch 3, 4.6 Closing, securing and supporting of doors 4.6.3 and taking account of the available space in the hull for adequate support.

4.10.7 The arrangement of securing devices and supporting devices in way of these securing devices is to be designed with redundancy so that in the event of failure of any single securing or supporting device the remaining devices are capable of withstanding the reaction forces, without exceeding, by more than 20 per cent, the permissible stresses as defined in Vol 1, Pt 4, Ch 3, 4.10 Design of securing and supporting devices 4.10.1.

4.11 Operating and Maintenance Manual

4.11.1 An Operating and Maintenance Manual for the doors is to be provided on board. The manual is to contain the following information:

  1. main particulars and design drawings,

    • special safety precautions;
    • details of vessel, class and statutory certificates;
    • equipment and design loading for ramps;
    • key plan of equipment for doors and ramps;
    • manufacturers' recommended testing for equipment; and
    • a description of the following equipment: side doors; stern doors; central power pack; bridge panel; ramps leading down from the main deck; engine control room panel.
  2. service conditions:

    • limiting heel and trim of the ship for loading/unloading;
    • limiting heel and trim for door operations;
    • operating instructions for doors and ramps and
    • emergency operating instructions for doors and ramps.
  3. maintenance:

    • schedule and extent of maintenance;
    • troubleshooting and acceptable clearances; and
    • manufacturers' maintenance procedures.
  4. register of inspections, including inspection of locking, securing and supporting devices, repairs and renewals.

4.11.2 The Manual is to be submitted for approval, and is to contain a note recommending that recorded inspections of the door supporting and securing devices be carried out by the ship’s staff at monthly intervals or following incidents that could result in damage, including heavy weather or contact in the region of the doors. Any damages recorded during such inspections are to be reported to LR.

4.11.3 Documented operating procedures for closing and securing the doors are to be kept on board and posted at an appropriate place.


Copyright 2022 Clasifications Register Group Limited, International Maritime Organization, International Labour Organization or Maritime and Coastguard Agency. All rights reserved. Clasifications Register Group Limited, its affiliates and subsidiaries and their respective officers, employees or agents are, individually and collectively, referred to in this clause as 'Clasifications Register'. Clasifications Register assumes no responsibility and shall not be liable to any person for any loss, damage or expense caused by reliance on the information or advice in this document or howsoever provided, unless that person has signed a contract with the relevant Clasifications Register entity for the provision of this information or advice and in that case any responsibility or liability is exclusively on the terms and conditions set out in that contract.